The Who, Journey, Tom Petty, Boston, The Eagles - none of these should be considered guilty pleasures! But Bee Gees, Michael Jackson, Aimee Man, Bangles, Bondie, Huey Lewis... WOW.
PS. I'm an ordained Baptist minister and I can't stomach Stryper. Moses, you really are suffering for the Lord
I'll have to add that I'm a sucker for Mary Chapin Carpenter. She's just anti-Nashville enough to earn my respect. Great singer and musician if you like that folkie-Americana stuff. Hunt down an mp3 of her version of the folk classic "Why Walk When You Can Fly?" or her own "I am a Town."